Ice Cream Toppings: add .75¢ each
Whipped Cream | Sprinkles | Cherries | Pecans | M&Ms | Cookie Crumbles | Almonds | Hot Fudge | Caramel | Raspberry Sauce | Hershey's Chocolate
* Allergen, Ask Server ** Gluten
Arabian Nights*: Golden dates, pistachio and sesame candy
Butter Beer 2016 Flavor of the Year: Butterscotch and Cinnamon
Caramel Crunch*: Dulce de Leche with Heath Bar crunch
Chocolate Brownie Bite**
Chocolate Cookie Dough**
Chocolate OMG!* Multiple National Blue Ribbon Winner
Cotton Candy
Madagascar Vanilla Multiple National Blue Ribbon Winner
Matcha-Strawberry Boba: A green tea ice cream with sweet boba balls
Mango
Mint Chip
Orange Creamsicle
Peanut Butter Oreo Fudge** *
Pumpkin Pie**
Raspberry Cheesecake Swirl**
Strawberries n Cream Blue Ribbon Winner
No Sugar Added Vanilla with Chocolate Swirl
SORBETS
Lemon Italian Ice Sorbet (Non Dairy)
Blue Raspberry Ice Sorbet (Non Dairy)
Orange Cream Ice Sorbet (Non Dairy)
PUPPY CREAM: Plain Yogurt mixed with Peanut Butter and Bacon for your Doggie!
4 Horsemen: Jack, Jameson, Johnny, Jim, Cherry base
Bailey's Irish Pistachio* National Award Winner
Bananas Foster: Fresh bananas, brown sugar, dark rum
Bourbon Butter Pecan* **: Bourbon and a whole homemade pecan pie
Buttery Scotchman: Vokda, Bailey's, Butterscotch Schanpps
Celtic Cream**: Guinness, Bailey's, Creme Brulee and white chocolate chips
Cherry Amaretto*: Cherries, Almonds, Amaretto
Drunken Oreo**: Oreos and Whipped Cream Vodka
The Dude, White Russian: Coffee Liqueur and Vodka
Flaming Pumpkin**: Pumpkin pie & Fireball whiskey
Harry's Brew: Butterscotch and Cinnamon Schnapps, Vodka
IT'S A TRAP!: Vanilla base with Amaretto, Bailey's and dark rum
Kentucky Salted Caramel: Makers Mark. Strong!
Legends Bourbon Bread Pudding**: Local distillery LEGENDS Bourbon and big chunks of our homemade bread pudding
Legends Vodka Sunrise: Local distillery LEGENDS Vodka, orange creamsicle and a raspberry swirl
Mudslide: Coffee Liqueur, Vodka, Irish Cream and chocolate swirl
Nutty Irishman: Espresso, Jameson, Frangelico
Parrothead Margarita: featuring Cap'n Buffet's signature gold tequila
Pina Colada*: Fresh pinapple, light rum, coconut
Royal Peach Cobbler**: featuring Crown Royal Peach
Rum-Chata: Horchata, cherries, light rum, Fireball and Bailey's
Rum Raisin: Raisins soaked in dark rum for months. Strong!
Skrewball*: Skrewball PB Whiskey and Reese's Cups
It Gives You Wiiiings!: Our take on a Vodka Redbull
Dingleberry: Ireland's Dingle Gin and a mix of fresh spring berries
Peach Buzz: Peaches and Moscato wine
Koppaberg Strawberry-Lime Hard Cider: Strawberry Sorbet with Koppaberg Hard Cider
Watermelon Sugar: Made with LEGENDS Vodka
Jack Collins: Lemon Sorbet with Jack Daniels