Hand Crafted Gourmet Ice Cream… the Ultimate Comfort Food… Insanely Delicious

2016 Flavor of the Year : Butter Beer *
2014 National Ice Cream Retailers Association Iron Scoop Champion
2015 Red Ribbon, Blue Ribbon, 3rd and 4th place Flavor of the Year Winner

Pint: $8
Quart: $14
Adult Pint: $10
Adult Quart: $18

Featured Flavors

1st Place

Butter Beer:
2016 FLAVOR OF THE YEAR

Butter Beer Reminiscent of Harry Potter, Butterscotch, and Cinnamon

• 2016 1st place Winner FLAVOR OF THE YEAR

Butter Beer Ice cream
3rd Place

Bailey’s Irish Pistachio:
2015 3rd Place Winner

Bailey’s Irish Pistachio Fresh Raw Pistachios in every bite and Irish Cream.

• 2015 3rd Place Winner FLAVOR OF THE YEAR

1st Place

Kentucky Salted Caramel:
2014 NICRA Iron Scoop Champion

Kentucky Salted Caramel A luscious blend of Kentucky Bourbon, Salted Caramel and Chocolate Chips.

• 2014 National Ice Cream Retail Association’s Iron Scoop Champion

Madagascar Vanilla:
Awarded a Red Ribbon in 2017!

Made with fresh Madagascar Vanilla Beans.

Strawberries and Cream:
Awarded a Red Ribbon in 2017!

Oh the texture of this ice cream is just beautiful, filled with delicious strawberries.

Our Unique Flavors

• Please note, not all flavors are in the store at the same time

Almond Brothers lots of Coconut and Almonds. Yummy.

Aunt Marty’s Chocolate Cake A one of a kind DaddyO’s recipe. This made- from- scratch chocolate cake with the homemade frosting ribboned throughout is a 100 year old recipe that will blow you away!

Butter Beer 2016 FLAVOR OF THE YEAR inspired by the Harry Potter movie, this is a rich butterscotch with butterscotch chips. Try our Adult version, Better Butter Beer.

Caramel Crunch It’s like melting 1,000 Caramels into fresh cream and adding Heath bars. Rich and Sensational! A house favorite.

Cookie Butter Pecan Our version of Butter Pecan made with Biscoff cookies.

Dole Whip Just like Disney but with DaddyO’s twist.

Egg Nog Made for the Holidays with a touch of booze!

Holy Cannoli Homemade Cannoli with mini chocolate chips and Cannoli shells

Lucky Leprechaun DaddyO invented this one to bring back the nostalgia of eating a bowl full of cold milk and Lucky Charms.

Mel’s Birthday Cake Oreo cookie with White Chocolate Chips and Rainbow Sprinkles

O’Crunch delicious Oreos and cream with Nestles crunch bars through out.

O’Fudge Oreo Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Sea Salt Fudge variegate.

Pumpkin Pie MommyO’s homemade pumpkin pie, crust and all.

Peppermint Stick for the Holidays

Re’s Rice Pudding Our signature flavor made with Great Grandma Re’s original Rice Pudding recipe. One taste and you’re Irish.

Snickery Are you cranky? A Snickers Ice cream will cheer you up.

Strawberry Rhubarb PieScream Vanilla Ice Cream with Lori’s homemade Strawberry Rhubarb pie tossed in, crust and all!

Sweet City Ambrosia Named after the city of Sugar Hill, a delicious ambrosia with sweet cream, pineapples, coconut, maraschino cherries and marshmallows.

Tamarind Apricot Coconut Orgy = T.A.C.O. Three exotic flavors entwined in ecstasy! A sweet and sour fruit from Africa, Organic Turkish Apricots and Flaky Coconut. A delicious blend of exotic fruits. Try it, you will love it. 4th Place winner in NICRA 2015 Flavor of the Year Competition.

Toasted Coconut Almond Little Leprechaun Lori’s concoction of fresh toasted coconuts, toasted almonds and a boatload of flavor. We can also make this flavor with Almond milk making it a non dairy, gluten free Ice Cream.

Our Chocolates

Chocolate OMG Velvety Ghirardelli Chocolate Mousse Ice Cream with Chocolate Sea Salt Fudge and mini Chocolate Chips. Chocolate lover’s dream. Our best seller.

Aunt Marty’s Chocolate Cake A one of a kind DaddyO’s recipe. This made- from- scratch chocolate cake with the homemade frosting ribboned throughout is a 100 year old recipe that will blow you away!

Chocolate Peanut Butter Bacon Oh yeah, we finally did it, we put bacon in ice cream. Can it get any better than that? Yeah, by adding chocolate and peanut butter.

Dutch Chocolate Mousse A simply divine rich and creamy Chocolate that is as smooth as mousse.

Hazelnut Mocha Latte Rich chocolate with Hazelnut and Coffee.

O’Fudge Vanilla Ice Cream with chunks of real Oreo Cookies variegated with rich chocolate sea salt fudge. Another house favorite.

Caramel Crunch It’s like melting 1,000 Caramels into fresh cream and adding Heath bars. Rich and Sensational! A house favorite.

O’Peanut Butter Fudge Oreo cookies and Cream Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Sea Salt Fudge variegate.

O’Mint Paddy You asked for Mint Chocolate so this is our unique recipe. Made with Mint Oreos and Andes Candies.

Smores Ghirardelli Chocolate Ice Cream with Marshmallows, Chocolate Fudge and Graham crackers

Our Fruits

Berry Berry Mo Berry Strawberry, Blueberry, Raspberry and Blackberry heaven

Salty Caramel Apple A comforting fall flavor

Cherry Vanilla Smooth and creamy Vanilla with delicious Bing Cherries

Creamsicle Orange and Cream

Dole Whip Similar to Disney but with a touch of DaddyO.

Georgia Peach Cobbler we take fresh Georgia Peaches in season and add cinnamon and brown sugar.

Key Lime Delicious, tangy, creamy, refreshing Key Lime .

Lemon Custard We created this recipe at a fan’s request. We think it came out pretty delicious.

Mango Sprouts had a sale on fresh Mangos and my what a delicious Ice cream it made. DaddyO didn’t like peeling them! Now we also use Fresh Mango fruit pulp imported from Columbia.

Passion Fruit An exotic fruit from Columbia. Very flavorful and delightful.

Strawberries n Cream Blue Ribbon Award winner, scored a perfect 10 on flavor. Oh the texture of this ice cream is just beautiful, filled with delicious strawberries.

Strawberry Rhubarb PieScream Vanilla Ice Cream with Lori’s homemade Strawberry Rhubarb pie tossed in, crust and all!

Traditional Favorites

DaddyO’s Madagascar Vanilla Red Ribbon Award winning Flavor. Made with fresh Madagascar Vanilla Beans.

M&M All American favorite. You will love it too.

Cotton Candy "Mommy I want pink ice cream!” Cotton Candy without the sticky fingers."

Sugar Free

Black Cherry

Peanut Butter Mocha

Vanilla Bean with Choc Chips

Italian Ices and Sorbets – Non Dairy

Lemon Fluff

Root Beer

Black Cherry Sorbet

Chocolate Sorbet

Adult Flavors

We offer a line of “Adult” flavored Ice Cream such as our Margarita, Blueberry Wine Sorbet, Kentucky Salted Caramel with Maker's Mark bourbon, Baileys with Toasted Marshmallows, and “The Dude” (White Russian).

Protein Ice Cream

For the Health minded, Dieters , Fitness Buffs and Bodybuilders check out our Spartan Series Protein Ice Creams.

See Flavors

Share Us with Your Friends!

Like what you see? Lick us on Facebook and share this page!